Over lunch this week, Madeleine Robins and I discussed a book we’ve both read more than once: Sinclair Lewis’s It Can’t Happen Here.
We have not re-read it recently, and neither of us is willing to do so right now, but as we know the story pretty well, we see the parallels all around us.
The title says a lot about American Exceptionalism, in that we in the United States really believe all kinds of its can’t happen here.
For those of you who haven’t read it, here’s a brief summary. In 1936, U.S. voters, apparently dissatisfied with Roosevelt’s reforms, elect a so-called populist (modeled on Huey Long of Louisiana) as president. The government is handed over without a fuss (sound familiar?) and the new president, Buzz Windrip, quickly establishes a fascist government.
Our hero is Doremus Jessup, editor and publisher of a small town paper, a man who ends up an active part of the resistance.
If you don’t know how strong fascism was in the United States in the 1930s and how much the oligarchs of the time hated Roosevelt, this might seem like fantasy to you, but there were good reasons for Lewis to write this book when he did. Lewis is not the most elegant writer and his satire was always a little heavy handed, but he really understood this country, or at least the white people of it.
I recommend it, though I’m not doing a re-read right now because I know the end of the book and the themes of many other resistance stories. I want stories about how we win, not just how we persevere.
As we cope with real life, there are two pieces of advice that I keep seeing over and over in the wake of the new presidential administration.
One is a reminder that the firehouse of nonsense from the grifter is intended to freak us all out and we should stay calm and not let it get to us.
And the other is we need to support institutions. History professor Timothy Snyder, whose studies focus on authoritarianism, included that in his latest newsletter of things to do and Marc Elias, who has been suing over voting rights in particular, included in his list of things to do “Help Democrats.”
While I certainly think it’s important not to let all these assaults on our fellow citizens and our democracy overwhelm us, I will point out that there needs to be a response to each of them. I don’t mean an individual response – that’s not even practical in most cases – but rather a response by an organization that knows how to deal with that problem.
A lot of that response will be litigation, though some of it – particularly when it comes to their attacks on immigrants – might be more focused on protecting people and holding demonstrations. Regardless, it needs to be led by groups that know what they’re doing, but the rest of us need to know that such work is happening and to get some idea of how we can support it.
In the case of those groups – those institutions – I think support (volunteering and financial) is very critical indeed. I have noticed that the ACLU, Public Citizen, and the Quakers have all filed relevant suits, and so have state attorneys general.
One of the actions over the executive order that is intended to nullify the 14th Amendment to the Constitution has already had success in the courts. But there will need to be a lot more of that just to hold a little ground.
In general, when I hear the word “protect institutions,” it’s those groups I have in mind, because they’re the ones that have been doing the work.
But I still kind of cringe when I hear “protect institutions,” because, frankly, a lot of the institutions failed to protect us.
I mean, the Republican Party started failing us 50 years ago. And while the Democratic Party when in power has done many of the things the people of this country need – the Affordable Care Act did improve a lot of people’s access to health care and various efforts by the Biden administration did markedly improve the infrastructure and work situation, not to mention that it has been the Democrats who have expanded our civil rights as well as our economic rights over my lifetime – they have continued to be too passive when dealing with threats to the core of our democracy.
I’m very tired of being told to vote hard and even more tired of hearing that we have to tolerate this abusive authoritarian regime because people didn’t turn out enough votes.
Brazil managed to block Bolsonaro from running for office. Why couldn’t our country do that? We even have a provision in the Constitution that addresses it, but nothing happened.
Which is to say, I don’t think the voters failed this country so much as I think a lot of our institutions did.
So before I do anything for Democrats stronger than send regular messages to my representatives and show up on election day to vote, I want to see some action by the leaders of the Democratic Party that tell me they’re actually going to do something this time. And I don’t mean individually on social media; I mean collectively in the Halls of Congress and as a party organizing for the future.
And that goes double for legacy media. I don’t like getting a lot of my news from newsletters and niche publications that are not capable of covering everything, but the established newspapers and other outlets are busy pretending this is just another change in administrations.
It’s not. I remember Reagan and Junior Bush and others of their ilk and their actions were bad, but this is levels worse. For one thing, they are taking away rights we worked decades, even centuries, to establish at the cost of many lives.
And the grifter can’t even address a tragedy without making racist and misogynist statements.
We have enough people dying these days from abysmal pandemic management and our farce of a health care system. We don’t need to make things worse.
Anyway, my solution is to pay enough attention so that you know what’s going on but aren’t reduced to screaming into the void, and to pick the places where you can do something and the institutions you can support.
And if you’re a federal worker or other person who suddenly finds yourself on the front lines when all you ever meant to do was your job, bless you and I hope you can stand your ground. We need you.
Because when it comes to fascists, there’s nothing exceptional about the United States.
As you might suspect one of the institutions I’d like to preserve is the FAA..
About an earlier coup attempt in the US, written just after the prior one.
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/coup-jan6-fdr-new-deal-business-plot-1276709/
The FAA is rather important, as we are seeing in light of the plane crash at National Airport.
That’s a terrifying story, one Lewis would probably have known about when he wrote It Can’t Happen Here. But it does prove my point: we are so bathed in the idea of American Exceptionalism that it’s hard to get people to see such plots as a real danger. And that, unfortunately, includes a lot of people who believe in our institutions so thoroughly that they don’t realize they have to protect them.
I was thinking the other night that people in 9-5 jobs who can’t do any of that, might get protection from a union (a very Aussie thought, by someone who was sidelined by unions). Although, to be far, everyone suddenly joining unions might cause unions to be outlawed. Trump is consistently Trumpian.
Many of the federal employees are unionized as well as having rights under the civil service laws, and some of the unions are bringing suit, which is a good thing.
I also think in terms of unions, in part because I was able to retire because I had a decent union. I really like the Aussie union attitude — I recall seeing a statue in Melbourne about them.
However, these rogues are attacking the National Labor Relations Board, which could cause problems for people expecting union protections from the law. As Cory Doctorow recently pointed out, people organized unions before it was legal and the laws are to the benefit of employers as well. On the other hand, if there are no legal protections, we’re back to the bloody fights (and I’m using that word literally, not as the British swear word) that got unions off the ground. I’m not thrilled about people dying to get their basic rights all over again.
This is where too much knowledge of US history is quite a bad thing. It really feels as if you’re returning to the days of the Shirtwaist Factory. I worry so much for you all.
My own explanation is that the traitors finally won the Civil War.
And since I know a lot of labor history, the thought of going back to people dying for the right to organize and get paid a living wage is very depressing.
But much as I pay attention to history, I do think we have to look not just as if history is repeating itself, but also take into account all the other things that bear on this and all the weak points in the grifter/broligarch/Christian extremist/other extremist coalition.
As an example: right now they’re demanding that people ignore climate change and wiping references to it out of government documents. But it isn’t going away. The broligarch approach to it is either bunkers or going to Mars, both of which are laughable. The Christian extremists are expecting the Second Coming and the rapture. The grifter doesn’t care and apparently some of the other extremists just don’t believe climate change is going to affect them. (And if you’re rich enough, you can shield yourself from a lot of it, though a lot of rich people lost their homes in LA as well as a lot of ordinary people for whom losing a home is a much bigger deal.)
Anyway, I veer from something’s got to give to panic every day. I just know I don’t want to persevere or resist; I want to win. There have got to be some creative solutions.